Buying guide

How to Choose a Winter Pool Cover Support

Updated on · By the Pool Care Pilot team

The right winter pool cover support keeps the cover tented, sheds snow and ice, and stops water from pooling on top. For most above ground pools, that means a center pillow plus a tight cable and winch, with water tubes or weights added for wind and decks.

On this page (11 sections)
  1. What does winter pool cover support actually do?
  2. How do you size support for a round pool?
  3. How does an air pillow support a cover in snow and ice?
  4. When do water tubes work better than an air pillow alone?
  5. How do cables and winches hold a cover tight?
  6. Which support suits oval pools and large top rails?
  7. How do you set up support step by step at closing?
  8. What care does support need through winter?
  9. How do you choose between pillow, tubes and a reel system?
  10. What are the trade offs between the covers and support here?
  11. How do you make the final winter pool cover support choice?

The right winter pool cover support keeps a cover tented in the middle, sheds snow and ice, and stops water from pooling on top. For most above ground pools, that means a center pillow plus a tight cable and winch.

Add water tubes or weights when wind or a deck makes the skirt hard to hold down.

Our team compared covers, pillows and weights by what each one does for support. We looked at overlap, scrim, material weight, cable and winch design, and how each setup fits round versus oval pools.

We did not test them in the field, so we label maker claims as claims. Our score weighs specs, features and buyer feedback against what you are shopping for.

Support does three jobs at once. It lifts the center so water runs off.

It spreads snow and ice load so the cover does not sag into the pool. It holds the edges so wind cannot lift a corner and fill the cover like a sail.

Start with your climate and your pool shape. Rain needs drainage support.

Snow needs load support. Wind needs edge support that holds the skirt flat.

The sections below break each choice down so you can pick one setup.

What does winter pool cover support actually do?

Winter pool cover support stops a cover going flat and water logged. An inflated pillow lifts the center into a shallow cone, so rain, snow melt and ice slide to the edges.

A tented cover also keeps load off the top rails. A sagging cover pulls on rails and traps debris that can stain the liner, which matters most on large round pools.

Support does not make a cover safe to walk on. Do not walk on it, and do not let children play on it.

Think of support as a system. The pillow gives shape, the cable and winch give tension, and tubes or weights give edge hold.

The goal is a calm, sloped cover that floats loosely on the water, as Robelle advises for its 24 ft Heavy Duty Super Winter cover.

Rule: buy support as a system, pillow plus cable plus edge hold, not as a cover alone.

How do you size support for a round pool?

Round pools are easiest to support because the center is the same distance from every edge. A pillow placed dead center lifts the cover evenly, so water runs off in every direction.

Size the pillow to the pool, not to the cover. An 18 ft pool needs a pillow that crowns the middle without poking past the edge, while a 24 ft pool needs a bigger pillow for the same slope.

Too small a pillow leaves a flat ring where water collects. Too large a pillow can push the cover up so high that the cable cannot pull the skirt down.

Overlap does not add middle support. Both Yankee covers here have a 4 ft overlap, and the Robelle also has a 4 ft overlap for a 28 ft finished size on a 24 ft pool.

That extra material folds over the top rail and gives the cable more to grip, which makes install easier. Do not size the pillow by the finished cover size.

Our swimming pool covers guide explains how overlap, scrim and material weight affect durability. Choose the right cover first, then size support to fit it.

Rule: size the pillow to the pool diameter, and size the cover by pool size plus overlap.

How does an air pillow support a cover in snow and ice?

An air pillow is the most common winter pool cover support for above ground pools. You inflate it, tie it off, set it in the center, and lay the cover over it.

The pillow holds the center up so snow and ice rest on a slope. Weight spreads toward the edges, where the cable and rails can carry it.

Pillow size matters more than brand. Too narrow a pillow leaves a valley down the middle, where snow fills in and melts into standing water.

A wider pillow creates a wider cone and sheds more water. Check the dimensions against your pool diameter before you buy.

Inflate it fully, then check it after a day of cold. Cold air contracts, so a pillow that felt firm in October can feel soft in January.

Top it up before the first big snow if it loses shape, and keep it clean and dry before storage.

Neither Yankee cover here includes a pillow. Yankee sells it separately for the 18 ft and 24 ft Sapphire covers, and Robelle sells its ice equalizer pillow separately for the 24 ft Heavy Duty Super Winter cover.

Rule: buy a pillow sized to your pool diameter, and check its air before the first snow.

When do water tubes work better than an air pillow alone?

Water tubes hold the skirt down but do not lift the center. You fill them and lay them along the edge so wind cannot lift a corner.

They work best with a pillow in the middle and a cable around the perimeter. That makes them the edge part of a system, not a full support on their own.

They help most on windy sites and on pools with no deck. Steady weight keeps a loose skirt from billowing in wind.

They also help on oval pools, where wind can catch the long side first. Our best pool cover water tubes guide compares tube types, counts and fill methods for that job.

Tubes take time to fill and drain, and a failed seam can leak onto the cover. Use the count the maker suggests and lay them flat so weight spreads evenly.

For a deck pool, tubes often sit on the deck over the skirt. For a partial deck, use tubes on the deck side and a cable on the open side, as the Robelle cover notes.

Rule: use tubes for edge hold on windy or deck pools, and pair them with a center pillow.

How do cables and winches hold a cover tight?

A cable and winch pull the skirt tight around the top rail. The cable runs through grommets around the edge, and the winch draws it in and locks it.

Tight edges keep wind and debris out and keep the cover from sliding off in a storm. All three covers here include a cable and winch.

The Robelle 24 ft Heavy Duty Super Winter includes a winch and cable for use through the grommets. Both Yankee Sapphire covers use a steel core cable through reinforced metal grommets, with a molded winch that turns to tighten the cable.

A steel core matters because a stretchy cord will loosen as the cover settles. Pull the cable snug, then check that the cover still floats loosely on the water.

Robelle warns that large top rails may need a larger cover size so the cover is not under stress. Over tight cables can tear grommets, pull the cover off the rail, or dimple the pool wall.

Route the cable evenly in small steps around the pool so the skirt pulls down evenly. Recheck tension after the first hard freeze and after any big wind event.

Rule: pull the cable snug and even, and leave the cover floating loosely on the water.

What support fits each cover here?

Support needs to match the cover you already own. A pillow that is right for an 18 ft pool will look small on a 24 ft pool.

A cable that is right for a round pool will fall short on an oval.

Match the pillow and tubes to the cover size, then check the fit by laying the cover over the pillow before you add water weight. If the crown looks flat, the pillow is too small.

If the skirt will not pull down, the cover or cable is too small.

Which support suits oval pools and large top rails?

Oval pools need support sized to both axes. A pillow that covers the width may still leave a flat channel along the length, where snow and melt collect.

Measure length and width, then size the pillow for the longer dimension at least. Some owners use a longer pillow or two pillows side by side to keep the whole oval crowned.

Large top rails change the fit too. A wide rail takes up material you expected to be skirt, so the cover sits under more stress and a tight cable can pull it off.

Robelle warns owners with large top rails to consider going up a pool size so the cover can float loosely. That advice applies to any brand.

Oval covers also need edge support along the long sides, where wind hits first and can lift a corner. Water tubes along the long skirt help hold it flat where a cable alone may leave the middle loose.

If your pool is oval, start with size specific picks. Our best 18x33 oval winter pool cover and best 15x24 oval pool winter cover pages match covers to those exact shapes.

Rule: size oval support to the long axis, and size up the cover for large top rails.

How do you set up support step by step at closing?

Set up support in a fixed order so you do not trap air or fold the cover. Clean the pool and lower the water to the level your maker suggests, then place the pillow in the center and inflate it fully.

Check that the pillow sits flat and does not touch the pool wall. Lay the cover over it and center it by hand, pulling the skirt down evenly on all sides.

Feed the cable through the grommets and join the ends. Use the winch to draw it in a little at a time as you walk around the pool, stopping when the cover feels snug but still floats loosely.

Add edge hold last, setting tubes along the skirt or on the deck over it until they sit flat and firm. Add cover clips or wrap after the tubes if you use them, as Robelle suggests both as extra securing, sold separately.

Do a final walk around the pool for a flat middle spot, a loose corner, or a lifting skirt. Fix those now, while the water is still warm enough to work in.

Rule: install in order, pillow first, then cover, then cable, then edge hold.

What care does support need through winter?

Support needs less care than the cover, but a monthly check helps. Air pillows lose air in cold weather, so press the pillow through the cover and top it up if it feels soft.

A soft pillow lets water pool, and pooled water adds weight that stresses seams. Check water tubes for freeze damage too, since a partly full tube can freeze and split or shift and leave a gap.

Keep tubes full and lying flat. If a tube leaks, drain it, dry it, and replace it before the next storm.

Clear snow and ice safely from the edge, and do not walk on the cover. Use a soft brush or broom from the side and push snow off in small loads.

Heavy snow left for weeks can overload even a well supported cover. If ice forms, let it melt or break it gently at the edge.

In spring, drain tubes fully, deflate the pillow, and dry all parts before storage in a cool, dry place. Yankee and Robelle both advise storing covers clean and dry, and the same care applies to tubes and pillows.

Clean the cover with mild soap and water and let it air dry, as Robelle directs.

Rule: check air, tube fill and snow load monthly, and dry everything before storage.

How do you choose between pillow, tubes and a reel system?

Choose by your main winter risk, not by what looks most complete. If water pooling is the problem, start with a pillow.

If wind lifting the skirt is the problem, start with tubes or weights.

If you close and reopen often and want faster handling, look at a reel system. A reel rolls the cover up for access during the season, rather than holding it down all winter.

For a winter cover that stays on for months, a reel adds cost and moving parts with little benefit. Our motorized pool cover reel guide explains when a reel makes sense for a solar or safety cover.

For a winter cover, a pillow plus cable usually does more for less money. A calm, sheltered yard may need only that, while a windy or deck pool may need tubes or weights on the deck side.

Match the extra part to the extra risk, and skip the rest. Both Yankee covers and the Robelle cover here include a cable and winch, so you do not need to buy those again, while the pillow, tubes and weights are separate on all three.

Rule: buy the support that fixes your main risk, pillow for pooling, tubes for wind, and skip a reel for a winter cover.

What are the trade offs between the covers and support here?

The three covers here show two approaches. Robelle uses heavy duty polyethylene at 2.36 oz per square yard with an 8 x 8 scrim, backed by a 10 year warranty.

Yankee uses denser 185 GSM material with a 14 x 14 scrim, which Yankee calls the industry top standard. Both rely on the same pillow plus cable support system.

Robelle suits a 24 ft round pool where you want a heavy cover with large overlap. Its 4 ft overlap makes a 28 ft finished cover, which eases install and gives the cable more skirt to hold.

Robelle says it is 18 percent heavier than industry standard and made for high wind areas, which helps it lie flat but makes handling heavier.

Yankee suits an 18 ft or 24 ft round pool where you want a thicker scrim and cold and UV resistance. Yankee says its LDPE coating withstands solar UV and the cover copes with cold as low as minus 10 degrees F.

Its steel core cable and molded winch give a firm grip, and both Yankee covers need a pillow bought separately.

Our best above ground winter pool covers and best intex pool winter cover pages compare these and other covers by size and use. If you later need a replacement motor for a reel system, our pool cover motor replacement guide covers that separate repair.

Rule: pick the cover by size and material, then pick support by climate and wind.

How do you make the final winter pool cover support choice?

Make the final choice with three measurements and one climate fact. Measure your pool diameter or oval axes, and measure your top rail width.

Note how much snow and wind you get in a normal winter.

For a standard round pool in a mild winter, a center pillow plus the included cable and winch is enough. For a large round pool in a snowy winter, size the pillow up so the crown reaches most of the center.

For a windy or deck pool, add tubes or weights along the skirt. For an oval pool, size support to the long axis and add edge hold on the long sides.

Use the covers here as size checks. The Yankee 18 ft Sapphire cover fits an 18 ft round pool with a 4 ft overlap.

The Yankee 24 ft Sapphire cover and the Robelle 24 ft Heavy Duty Super Winter fit a 24 ft round pool, with the Robelle at a 28 ft finished size. If your pool falls between sizes or has a large top rail, step up a cover size rather than forcing a tight fit.

Rule: pick pillow plus cable for most pools, add tubes for wind or decks, and size up for ovals and large rails.

Frequently asked questions

What is winter pool cover support?

Winter pool cover support is the gear under or around a cover that holds it up and tight. A center pillow lifts the middle so rain and melt run off.

A cable and winch pull the edges tight.

Tubes or weights hold the skirt down in wind.

Does a winter pool cover need a pillow?

Most above ground pools benefit from a pillow, especially in snow country. The pillow creates a crown in the center.

That crown lets water drain to the sides instead of sitting in a sag.

A flat cover with no crown collects water and strains the seams.

Can water sit on a winter pool cover?

Standing water adds weight fast and can push a cover down into the pool. It also slows airflow and can grow algae on the underside.

Support that keeps the cover sloped helps water leave.

Today the quick check is whether the center stays higher than the edges after rain.

How tight should a pool cover cable be?

The cable should pull the cover drum tight with no loose skirt flapping, but the cover should still float loosely on the water. The Robelle 24 ft Heavy Duty Super Winter notes that same balance in its setup advice.

Over tightening can stress grommets and pull the cover off a large top rail.

What support works best for oval pools?

Oval pools need support sized to both axes, not just the longest side. A pillow that is too short leaves a flat channel down the middle.

Measure length and width, then size the pillow and cover for the larger dimension.

Our oval specific picks below help you match the shape.